Statistics Prove It! Being an MU Coach is the Hardest Job in the World!

Gilabola.com – Being a Manchester United coach turns out to be one of the hardest jobs on earth, since the death of Sir Alex Ferguson there has not been a single manager who is considered successful at Old Trafford. Want to see how each coach compares? Keep reading until the end of this article!

Amorim’s Ultimatum That Ended in a Dead End

Ruben Amorim was officially fired by Manchester United after the 1-1 draw against Leeds United on Sunday night WIB, a decision taken by management even though the Red Devils are still in sixth place in the Premier League standings.

These results capped Amorim’s tumultuous period at Old Trafford. Both before and after the match, the Portuguese coach again delivered confrontational statements in a press conference, which were directed directly at club officials.

For Amorim, the “support me or fire me” attitude turned out to be a double-edged sword. The previous season, he had recorded a dark history by leading Manchester United to finish in their worst position in the Premier League era.

Even though United are currently still in sixth place and still in the hunt for Champions League tickets, consistency of performance is the main problem. Club management, led by CEO Omar Berrada and director of football Jason Wilcox, considers this target more realistic to achieve without Amorim.

“With Manchester United in sixth place in the Premier League, the club leadership has reluctantly decided that now is the right time to make a change. This will give the team the best opportunity to achieve the highest possible position in the Premier League,” read the club’s official statement.

This decision means United are now looking for a seventh permanent manager in a little more than 12 and a half years since the legendary era of Sir Alex Ferguson ended.

List of Manchester United Managers after Sir Alex Ferguson

Manchester United’s journey since 2013 has been marked by successive changes in coaches. Each era brings new hope, but also leaves behind stories of failure and inconsistency.

David Moyes: Promising Beginning, Bittersweet Ending

David Moyes came as “The Chosen One” Sir Alex Ferguson’s direct choice. Initially, United won the Community Shield and opened the season with a landslide 4-1 win over Swansea City.

However, a 1-0 defeat to Liverpool at Anfield and a 4-1 defeat to Manchester City were turning points. Two humiliating 3-0 defeats at Old Trafford to these two rivals, followed by defeat to Everton at Goodison Park, ended Moyes’ reign before his first season had even finished.

Louis van Gaal: High Discipline, Low Entertainment

Louis van Gaal arrived with a great reputation after guiding the Netherlands to a third-place finish at the 2014 World Cup. However, a 5-3 defeat to a Jamie Vardy-inspired Leicester City changed the course of the season.

United’s playing style under Van Gaal was considered too slow and stiff. Even though he returned to the Champions League and won the FA Cup, finishing sixth in the 2015/16 season meant he still lost his position.

Jose Mourinho: Trophy amidst tension

Jose Mourinho led United to the Carabao Cup and Europa League, making his first season the most successful post-Ferguson in terms of trophies.

However, a deteriorating relationship with key players such as Paul Pogba as well as declining form saw him sacked after a defeat to Liverpool in December 2018.

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer: Stable but Not Perfect

Solskjaer may not have offered a tactical revolution, but he managed to restore a positive atmosphere. United finished second in the 2020/21 season and almost won the Europa League.

The foundations that had been established collapsed after the return of Cristiano Ronaldo, and a crushing defeat to Watford in November 2021 ended his tenure.

Ralf Rangnick: Open Criticism Without Real Results

Rangnick arrived with a reputation for gegenpressing, but the reality of United’s squad did not support his ideas. Big defeats from City and Liverpool occurred again.

Open criticism of a squad that he considered unsuitable for modern football made his tenure feel more like a transition than a solution.

Erik ten Hag: Bright Beginnings, Bleak Ending

Ten Hag started the era promisingly, including winning the Carabao Cup and eliminating Cristiano Ronaldo. However, the 7-0 defeat to Liverpool was a wound that never healed.

Despite adding the FA Cup, poor league performance made his new contract feel misguided until he was finally sacked in October 2024.

Ruben Amorim and Unrealized Hope

Great hopes accompany the arrival of Ruben Amorim from Sporting CP. The 4-1 victory over Manchester City in the Champions League with his old club made enthusiasm peak.

He won the Manchester Derby in December 2024 and took a firm stance against star players such as Marcus Rashford and Alejandro Garnacho, which was initially welcomed positively.

However, the results speak differently. Finishing in 15th place in the Premier League and defeat in the Europa League final to Tottenham were big blemishes. Despite receiving support in the transfer market, Amorim failed to prove himself, and his ultimatum actually hastened the end of his career at Old Trafford.

Comparison of Manchester United Managers Since Sir Alex Ferguson

Gilabola.com’s views

In our opinion, Ruben Amorim’s dismissal actually confirms that Manchester United still hasn’t really learned from past mistakes. Too often this club is trapped between the coach’s idealism and the reality of performance, then chooses shortcuts when the results don’t come. Amorim failed, but United’s problems feel much more structural than just who sits in the manager’s chair. Want to know Manchester United’s most expensive lessons and wasteful habits? Read this article about how expensive Ruben Amorim is for the Red Devils!